Why WindRiver · Comparison guide
Gated lakefront
communities in Tennessee
A real comparison of amenities, pricing, and lifestyle on Tellico Lake.
Tellico Lake at a glance
16,000
Acres of lake
373
Miles of shoreline
~270
Homes for sale at any time
5
Communities compared
The real question
Which community fits the way you want to live?
Tellico Lake is home to some of the most compelling gated communities in East Tennessee. If you’re figuring out where to buy — a retirement home, a second place, an investment property — you’ve probably already come across the main players: Tellico Village, Rarity Bay, Kahite, WindRiver, Legacy Shores. They’re all solid, and genuinely different in size, feel, amenities, and price point.
The real question isn’t which community is “best.” It’s which one is best for you.
This guide walks through each major Tellico Lake gated community, breaks down what makes them distinct, and who they actually suit.
Why gated
Why a Gated Community Over Standalone Lakefront
Gated developments tend to outperform standalone lakefront properties, from both a lifestyle and investment standpoint.
01
Investment
Gated communities with professional HOA management tend to appreciate more consistently than standalone properties. Amenities like championship golf and marinas directly boost both rental rates and resale appeal. A gated community home on Tellico Lake typically rents for 50–75% more per night than a standalone lakefront, and sells faster with less back-and-forth.
02
Lifestyle
Golf, boating, dining, fitness — it’s all in one place. You’re not juggling separate dock maintenance, hunting down individual contractors, or coordinating everything yourself. Professional management handles the common areas, security, and amenity operations, which is a genuine perk for buyers who value their time.
03
Stability
Communities with solid HOA governance and well-kept amenities hold value better when markets soften. Professional management, community standards, and integrated infrastructure all work as built-in protection.
What to look for
What Makes a Gated Lakefront Community Actually Worth It
Not all gated communities are playing the same game. Here are six things worth evaluating as you compare Tellico Lake options:
01
Golf Course Quality (Tier 1)
Championship vs. recreational is a real gap — a proper 18-hole course by a respected architect, especially one with environmental certification, signals serious luxury positioning and pulls in premium guests.
02
Marina & Water Access (Tier 1)
A full-service marina with fuel, maintenance, and slip availability is a different world from a boat launch. Slip size range and year-round accessibility matter to serious boaters.
03
Fine Dining & Clubhouse (Tier 2)
On-site dining with lake views creates a natural gathering spot and lifts the lifestyle feel — compare a signature restaurant versus occasional food options.
04
Fitness & Wellness (Tier 2)
Some communities have 27,000+ sq ft wellness centers; others have a room with a treadmill. Thirty miles of trails versus two in-community is a real difference.
05
Community Culture (Tier 2)
A hundred-plus clubs and constant programming versus a quieter, more intimate vibe — neither is better, just different. Know what you want before you shop.
06
Amenity Integration (the differentiator)
Can you golf, dine, boat, and work out without leaving the property? True integration is what separates a gated community from a nice neighborhood.
The setting
Tellico Lake: The Setting
Tellico Lake covers 16,000 acres with 373 miles of shoreline, sitting in the foothills of the Great Smoky Mountains, 30 minutes from Knoxville and about 90 minutes from Gatlinburg. TVA controls water levels, which means consistent conditions year-round — good for boating, good for waterfront values.
01
The Market
Around 270 homes are listed for sale on Tellico Lake at any given time — enough liquidity to buy and sell without headaches, without being so oversaturated that pricing goes soft. The buyer profile skews affluent, active, and educated: retirees from professional careers, second-home buyers, investors.
02
Why Here
Tellico Lake isn’t a generic lake community that accidentally became upscale. Cooper Communities launched Tellico Village in 1986 and established the market as premium from the start, creating a positive feedback loop: quality buyers attracted quality amenities, which attracted more quality buyers, which supported ongoing investment. The result is a lake with multiple championship-quality communities competing on excellence rather than racing to the bottom.
Side by side
Community breakdown: a reference
Aspect | Tellico Village | Rarity Bay | Kahite | WindRiver | Legacy Shores |
Size | 4,600 acres | 960 acres | 850 acres | 687 acres | 99 homesites |
Golf Courses | 3 championship | 1 championship | 1 (shared) | 1 championship | None |
Marina | 5 marinas | Community marina | Shared access | Premier marina | None |
Fine Dining | Multiple options | None on-site | None on-site | Citico’s Lakeside Inn | None |
Fitness | 27,000 sq ft wellness | Fitness center | Activity center | None | |
Trails | Limited | 4 miles | Shared access | 30+ accessible miles | None |
Residents | ~7,000 | ~1,500 | Growing | ~500-700 | ~150 |
Clubs/Groups | 100+ | Curated selection | Tellico Village system | Growing | None |
HOA Fees | ~$1,000/year | ~$653/year | ~$1,000/year | Varies | Lowest |
Pricing | $100K-$900K+ | $300K-$1M+ | $500K-$800K | $350K-$800K+ | $300K-$600K |
Best For | Social retirees | Exclusive lifestyle | Newest homes | Complete resort living | Boating enthusiasts |
Community profiles
The communities, up close
Tellico Village
Community
Tellico Village: The Established One
Founded: 1986 (oldest on the lake)
Size: 4,600 acres, 40 miles of shoreline, around 7,000 residents across eight neighborhoods
Vibe: Established small-town feel with serious social infrastructure
Golf: Three championship courses — Tanasi, Toqua, and The Links at Kahite — designed by Ault, Clark & Associates (the firm behind Congressional Country Club). Mature, well-maintained, well-regarded. The model is pay-as-you-go rather than mandatory membership, which golfers who want flexibility tend to appreciate.
Marina: Five separate marinas plus a yacht club. Lots of options, but the experience is spread out rather than centralized — works well for boaters who want choices.
Dining: Multiple neighborhood dining options rather than one signature restaurant. Activity disperses across the community rather than concentrating.
Fitness: The Wellness Center is the crown jewel — 27,000 square feet, modern gym, two fitness studios, sauna, heated pools. Significantly bigger than most communities.
Community: 100+ clubs and organizations, an extremely active social calendar. Leagues, classes, events — something is always going on. If being plugged in is the priority, this is the place.
Pricing: $100,000–$900,000+ (widest range on the lake)
HOA: ~$1,000/year
Best for: Retirees who want to stay busy and social. Golfers who prefer flexibility. Budget-conscious buyers who still want a full amenity community. Boaters who want marina variety.
Bottom line: The most established community on the lake, with proven infrastructure, maximum amenity variety, and an active social scene — traded off against a less intimate feel, since amenities are spread across 4,600 acres.
Rarity Bay
Community
Rarity Bay: The Exclusive One
Location: Bat Creek Peninsula, Tellico Lake
Size: 960 acres, 10 miles of shoreline, ~1,500 residents
Vibe: Exclusive waterfront living with mountain elegance
Setting: Rarity Bay sits on a peninsula with water on multiple sides. That geography gives it some of the best Smoky Mountain views on the lake — some people think the best in all of East Tennessee. The limited homesites and gated peninsula feel create a sense of exclusivity that larger communities can’t replicate.
Golf: One 18-hole championship course designed by D.J. DeVictor and Peter Langham, with mountain views integrated throughout. Golf membership is included with property purchase rather than optional.
Marina: Community marina, adequate for slip rentals but not full-service. Many properties have private boat docks with direct water access, a draw for serious boaters.
Dining: No on-site restaurant — a real difference from communities that have one.
Fitness: Basic fitness center and activity facilities, less comprehensive than Tellico Village.
The differentiator: Equestrian. Rarity Bay has horse stables, riding trails, and boarding. If that’s part of your lifestyle, this is the only Tellico Lake community that speaks to it.
Community: Curated rather than sprawling. Smaller resident base, more intimate social dynamic. Strong club culture and organized events, just fewer total clubs than Tellico Village.
Pricing: $300,000–$1,000,000+ (premium)
HOA: ~$653/year (technically the lowest, but covers fewer amenities)
Best for: Buyers who want exclusivity and intimacy over scale. Equestrian enthusiasts. Golfers who prefer one course with included membership. People drawn to those mountain views. Buyers who want a curated community rather than a programming-heavy one.
Bottom line: The peninsula geography is the real differentiator — stunning views and natural seclusion. Skip it if you need an on-site restaurant or a big wellness center; choose it if you value intimate community over maximum activity.
Kahite
Community
Kahite: The Newest One
Location: Newest neighborhood in the Tellico Village system
Size: 850 acres, surrounded by water on three sides
Vibe: New construction with full access to an established system
What makes it different: Kahite is the newest neighborhood within the Tellico Village umbrella. You get a brand-new home while tapping into Tellico Village’s full amenity network — three golf courses, five marinas, the big wellness center, 100+ clubs.
Geography: Water on three sides means dramatic lake views from a lot of lots. Higher-elevation properties have panoramic views that are hard to beat anywhere on the lake.
Homes: Modern floor plans, contemporary finishes, energy-efficient builds — this is where you go if you want new construction instead of a resale.
Golf & Amenities: Full access to Tellico Village’s system — three championship courses, multiple marinas, large wellness center, 100+ clubs. Worth noting: those amenities serve the broader 7,000-resident system.
Pricing: $500,000–$800,000 (new construction premium)
HOA: ~$1,000/year (same as Tellico Village)
Best for: Buyers who want new construction with modern finishes. Golf enthusiasts who want course variety. People who want fresh homes alongside established amenity infrastructure.
Bottom line: Kahite solves a specific problem — contemporary construction with proven amenities around it — in exchange for being part of a 7,000-person system rather than a standalone community, at new-construction prices.
WindRiver
Our community
WindRiver: The Complete Resort Experience
Location: Lenoir City shoreline, Tellico Lake
Size: 687 acres, established and expanding (Clubhouse Village launching 2026)
Vibe: Championship golf + premier marina + fine dining + fitness, all in one independent community
What sets it apart: WindRiver is the only community on Tellico Lake integrating all four major amenities — championship golf, full-service marina, on-site fine dining, and comprehensive fitness — in a single independent community.
Championship Golf Course: The centerpiece is a Bob Cupp-designed championship course, Tennessee’s first Audubon-certified course. Cupp was a Jack Nicklaus protégé, and the course shows it: six tee sets (4,146–7,453 yards), Prism Zoysia greens, lake and mountain views on nearly every hole. The Audubon certification is genuinely rare — a prestige signal and an environmental one that appeals to a specific kind of luxury buyer and adds a differentiator in a competitive market.
Marina: Full-service marina with covered slips from 30ft to 90ft, fuel (regular and premium), shore power, water, private restrooms, and pump-out. Slip pricing runs $265–$850/month depending on size (less for members) — resort-quality marina infrastructure, not just a dock. A legitimate full-service marina pulls in premium vacation renters and serious boaters, and properties near it tend to command 30–50% rental premiums.
Citico’s Lakeside Inn: Fine dining at the Lakeside Inn, with panoramic Tellico Lake views — the amenity that separates WindRiver from every other community on the lake. On-site fine dining creates a natural community gathering point and meaningfully elevates the lifestyle. Vacation rental guests book at higher nightly rates when fine dining is walkable, and residents don’t have to leave the community for a real dinner.
Fitness: Full fitness center, resort-style pool, sports complex (tennis, pickleball, basketball), and hiking/walking trails, with access to 30+ miles of the East Lakeshore Trail System.
Coming in 2026: Clubhouse Village. A major expansion with a new clubhouse, pro shop pavilion, and enhanced amenities. While other communities maintain older infrastructure, WindRiver is adding new.
Community scale: Around 500–700 resident households — meaningfully smaller than Tellico Village’s 7,000, which creates a more intimate feel while still supporting the full amenity package.
Membership: Championship Golf membership ($730/month) covers unlimited golf, waived greens and cart fees, 30-day advance tee times, and priority marina slip leasing. Social & Yacht membership ($330/month) gives access to the community without unlimited golf play.
Pricing: $350,000–$800,000+ (mid-luxury — below Rarity Bay, above the entry end of Tellico Village)
Club initiation: $100,000 one-time (can be split between buyer and seller)
Best for: Golf enthusiasts wanting a championship course, boaters who need a real marina, investment buyers chasing top rental rates, and retirees who want everything integrated without leaving the community.
Competitive advantages: The only Audubon-certified championship course in Tennessee, the only full-service premier marina on Tellico Lake, and the only on-site fine dining — all in one independent 687-acre community at mid-luxury pricing, with the biggest amenity expansion on the lake arriving in 2026.
Bottom line: WindRiver is built for one buyer: championship golf, a real marina, fine dining, and fitness, all without leaving the community. No other Tellico Lake community delivers all four.
The Smaller Players: Legacy Shores, Foothills Pointe, Harbour Place
Legacy Shores: 99 homesites, 80% with direct dock access. Purpose-built for boaters. No golf, no dining, minimal fitness. Best for serious boaters who want dock access above everything else.
Foothills Pointe: East side of the lake, lake-view lots (not waterfront). Budget-friendly entry into the lake lifestyle without waterfront pricing.
Harbour Place: On the Maryville side (20 minutes to Maryville versus 30 to Knoxville). Community dock, boat launch, still developing. Best for buyers who want to be closer to Maryville.
Pricing & HOA
Financial Breakdown: Pricing & HOA at a Glance
Community | Entry Price | Typical $500K Value | HOA | Total Annual Cost | Best Value For |
Tellico Village | $100K+ | $500K | $1,000 | $1,000 | Budget consciousness |
Kahite | $500K | $550K | $1,000 | $1,000 | New construction |
WindRiver | $350K+ | $500K | Varies* | $6,000-$8,400* | Complete amenities |
Rarity Bay | $300K+ | $600K+ | $653 | $653 | Exclusivity |
Legacy Shores | $300K | $400K | Low | ~$300-500 | Boating only |
What this means
On raw HOA alone, Rarity Bay and Legacy Shores win. But those numbers don’t account for golf membership value, marina quality, or dining. When you price out the full lifestyle — not just the HOA line item — WindRiver makes a strong case for buyers who want everything integrated.
Decision framework
Decision Framework: Which One Is Actually Right for You?
Best for
GOLF
WindRiver (Audubon championship course, unlimited golf) or Tellico Village (three courses, pay-as-you-go).
Best for
Boating/marina
WindRiver (full-service marina, 30–90ft slips), Tellico Village (five marinas), or Legacy Shores (purely boating-focused, direct docks).
Best for
Maximum social activity
Tellico Village (100+ clubs, constant programming) or WindRiver (growing social calendar).
Best for
Newest homes
Kahite (newest construction, modern finishes) or WindRiver (newer community, big expansion incoming).
Best for
Intimate community feel
Rarity Bay (1,500 residents, peninsula setting) or Legacy Shores (99 homesites, pure boating community).
Best for
All amenities integrated
WindRiver is the only community with all four; Tellico Village has all four but spread across 4,600 acres.
Buying as investment: WindRiver (complete amenity package, premium rental rates 50–75% above standalone) or Tellico Village (established market, consistent appreciation).
Lowest total costs: Tellico Village (lowest HOA ~$1,000/year, widest price range) or Rarity Bay (lowest HOA at $653, but higher home prices).
Due diligence
Before You Commit: A Due Diligence Checklist
When you’re ready to get serious, ask the community management about: financial health (HOA reserve fund status, upcoming capital projects, five-year budget forecast); property values (average annual appreciation — 3–4% is realistic for Tellico Lake — days on market, price per square foot trends); community satisfaction (do current owners actually like it, and do they stay long-term?); amenity quality (golf course and marina maintenance budgets, restaurant and fitness facility upkeep); and, if investing, rental potential — average nightly rates for vacation rentals, seasonal occupancy, and short-term rental rules.
Questions
Common Questions
Size, maturity, and how integrated the amenities are — from Tellico Village’s scale and variety to Rarity Bay’s exclusive peninsula setting to WindRiver’s fully integrated golf-marina-dining package in one 687-acre community.
All Tellico Lake communities run at about 3–4% annually. Gated communities with professional management tend to outpace standalone lakefront, and golf frontage, dock access, and marina proximity all command premiums within a community.
Yes, all communities allow it. WindRiver properties tend to rent at a 30–50% premium ($200–$280/night) versus standalone lakefront ($120–$160/night) because of the golf, marina, and dining combination.
$653–$1,000 per year for base HOA, plus golf memberships (where separate) ranging $300–$730/month. Budget for property tax, insurance, utilities, and club fees together.
Yes — Tellico Village has plenty in the $100K–$400K range. WindRiver, Kahite, and Rarity Bay typically start around $300K–$350K for interior lots; waterfront and dockable properties go well above $500K.
All of them serve retirees well — it depends what you’re optimizing for: social activity (Tellico Village), golf (WindRiver), boating (Legacy Shores), or intimate and exclusive (Rarity Bay).
Gated communities generally outperform standalone lakefront on appreciation (3–4% vs. 2.5–3%) and rental income (50–75% higher nightly rates). You’re trading some autonomy for stability, amenities, and professional management.
Every community has a sales office and most run discovery tour programs. Visit multiple communities separately, and if you can, rent in one for a week before deciding — a weekend tells you something; a week tells you everything.
Compare in person
See WindRiver for yourself
A lakeside, master-planned community on Tellico Lake — championship golf, a full marina and 30 miles of trails, minutes from Knoxville.
© 2026 WindRiver Tennessee. All rights reserved.